Ask Mary: Value of cast iron collection – Where to start?
I received a note from Tammy of Shepherdsville, Kentucky, asking how best to learn about and value her father’s collection of vintage and antique cast iron cookware.
Tammy wrote:
“My dad was an Griswold and Wagner collector and I do mean a lot of stuff I am wanting to know which book I should buy the red or blue book I [saw] there was a muffin one also. I have quite a lot of muffin pans do I need all 3 to research to sell and are the prices current in these books…”
Well Tammy, it sounds like you have your hands full of wonderful old iron! If you plan to sell the collection piece by piece—on Facebook Marketplace, eBay, or Etsy—here are a few starting points.
The “Blue” and “Red” Griswold and Wagner Books
I typically recommend starting with the Blue Book by David Smith and Chuck Wafford. It’s rich with photographs and history of Griswold and Wagner cookware, with information on Sidney Hollow Ware, Favorite, and Wapak as well.1
Their Red Book expands on that material, with more emphasis on Wagner. It also covers Lodge, Martin, Vollrath, and Excelsior Stove Works.
If you have many Griswold gem and muffin pans, Jon Haussler’s Griswold Muffin Pans is useful for identifying variations and relative scarcity. Its focus is Griswold, so it won’t be nearly as helpful if your muffin pans are by other makers.
Pricing Individual Pieces in a Collection
The prices in these books are dated. They may help you understand relative scarcity, but I wouldn’t use them to set today’s selling prices.
I’ve watched cast iron prices rise and fall over the years. My auction-results posts show just how much prices can vary. As far as I’m concerned, the best starting point for a piece’s current value is what people are actually paying for comparable pieces. An asking price is just that—an asking price.
Compare the same maker, size, markings, and variation, in similar condition. Cracks, warping, pitting, missing parts, and the condition of the surface all matter. Two pans with the same logo may be very different purchases.
My guide to finding sold prices on eBay and other auction sites walks through the research. Look at several recent sales rather than relying on one unusually high or low result.
Help from Collectors and Auctioneers
The Griswold & Cast Iron Cookware Association’s Facebook group and the Wagner and Griswold Society can be great resources. The G&CICA group is private; you’ll need to request to join. When asking for help, include clear photos, markings, measurements, and condition details.
Google and ChatGPT can help you find leads, too. Check the identifications and price claims against reliable references and actual sales.
For a large collection, consider an auction house experienced in vintage cast iron, such as Simmons & Company Auctioneers in Missouri or Dinky’s Auction Center in Indiana. An auction lets bidders set the selling price. You could also hire a knowledgeable appraiser to examine the collection and give a considered opinion of fair market value.
I hope this gives you a useful place to start, Tammy. Good luck!

