A large two-day cast iron collector’s auction was held on November 13 and 14, 2025 at Dinky’s Auction Center in Montgomery, Indiana. Pieces offered were primarily from several long-time collectors.
As you review the auction prices shown below, bear in mind that the prices are the gavel price – i.e. they do not include any additional fees such as buyer’s premium (20% buyer’s premium for online bids; no buyer’s premium for on-site bids), sales tax, or any shipping charges (Dinky’s charged a $15 “box” fee, plus actual shipping cost plus insurance).
You can read much, much more about large vintage cast iron collector’s auctions and auction results by viewing my posts in the “Cast Iron Auctions and Auctioneers” category of the blog.
Day 1 Top Five Prices Realized
All information and photos are from the Dinky’s auction catalog.
Day 2 Top Five Prices Realized
More
Following are the items that sold for $1,000 or more on both days.
- “ERIE” H.E. Hessler Coffee Grinder, $3,600
- Griswold 3-Tier Dutch Oven Stand, PN 1065, $3,500
- Griswold Cast Iron Trivet no. 13, $3,400
- Griswold Umbrella Stand base (with crack), $3,400
- Griswold no. 00 Cast Iron Flop Waffle Iron PN 911, $2,500
- Griswold Rabbit Mold Extender, $2,500
- Griswold Aluminum Bundt Pan PN A65, $2,500
- Griswold Bailed no. 14 Cast Iron Skillet, Large Block Logo EPU, $2,300
- Griswold no. 14 4-Section Cast Iron Hotel Waffle Iron, $2,000
- Griswold no. 13 Slant Logo EPU Cast Iron Skillet, $2,300
- Griswold no. 1 Cast Iron Flop Waffle Iron PN 907, $2,000
- Griswold no. 2 Cast Iron LBL EPU Skillet PN 703, $2,000
- Griswold no. 13 Plated Cast Iron Skillet Large Block Logo EPU, $1,900
- Griswold Slant Logo no. 13 Dutch Oven Bottom only, Slant Logo EPU, $1,900
- Griswold no. 13, 3-Section Cast Iron Hotel Waffle Iron, $1,800
- Griswold no. 8 Cast Iron Lid, Bicentennial Geo. Washington, $1,800
- Griswold Plated Cast Iron Cowboy Hat Ashtray, $1,600
- Griswold 3-Tier Dutch Oven Stand, PN 1065, $1,600
- Griswold no. 8 Cast Iron Lid, Bicentennial Geo. Washington, $1,600
- Griswold “ERIE” Slant Logo no. 2 Cast Iron Skillet w Heat Ring, $1,550
- Selden & Griswold French Waffle Iron 3 Paddle, $1,500
- “ERIE” Cast Iron Artistic Logo Skillet no. 5, PN 3348, $1,450
- Griswold no. 13 Cast Iron Dutch Oven and Lid (Dutch Oven “a little rough”) $1,400
- Griswold no. 20 Cast Iron Hotel Skillet, $1,400
- Griswold Cast Iron Oval Skillet Cover no. 15, $1,400
- Griswold Griddle Rack, $1,400
- Griswold no. 2 Flop Waffle Iron PN 905, $1,300
- Griswold no. 3 Low Dome Plain Cast Iron Skillet Lid, $1,200
- Griswold Cast Iron Vienna Roll Pan, variation 4, $1,200
- Atlantic Cast Iron Loaf Pan, $1,150
- Griswold Cast Iron no. 2 Smooth Bottom LBL EPU Skillet, PN 703, $1,100
- Wagner no. 2 Cast Iron Pie Logo Skillet, $1,100
- “ERIE” Artistic Logo Cast Iron Skillet no. 5, $1,100
- Griswold “All in One” Cast Iron Dinner Skillet, $1,050
- Griswold no. 14 Cast Iron Fully-Marked Skillet Lid, $1,000
- Griswold Coffee Grinder, $1,000
