Seared steaks in a BSR cast iron skillet with the title “Cabin Steak in the BSR Skillet.”

Cooking Steak in a Cast Iron Skillet on a Chilly Cabin Weekend

A cold, rainy weekend on Lake Superior wasn’t what we had in mind. But a warm cabin and a crusty old BSR pan gave me a chance to cook steak in a cast iron skillet. It turned out to be a very good dinner.

In June 2018, I headed to Cornucopia, Wisconsin, to visit my friends Louise and Tom at Siskiwit Bay Marina, where they kept their 35-foot sailboat.1 I had camped beside their slip many times over 23 years, enjoying summer sails and beach walks with our dogs.

Sailboats at Siskiwit Bay Marina in Cornucopia, Wisconsin.
Siskiwit Bay Marina, with Louise and Tom’s boat in the foreground.

Good Golly, It Was Cold…and Wet!

The week before, the Twin Cities had reached 98°F. By Friday evening at the marina, it was gusty and in the mid-40s. Louise helped me pitch my tent, and we spent the evening visiting and nibbling hors d’oeuvres in the boat’s salon.

I slept well, bundled into a cool-weather sleeping bag with extra blankets and a toasty, tired Maltese. On Saturday, rain battered the boat while Louise and I worked on our computers. Tom went to check on a friend’s cabin nearby.

We had planned to grill steaks, but the rain wasn’t letting up. We headed for the cabin instead. The car’s thermometer read 39°F. On went the seat heaters and defrosters.

A Warm Cabin and a Crusty BSR Skillet

Tom had a great fire going in the wood-burning stove. Maisie and Meg, the Golden Retriever, settled in for a nap while we started dinner.

The cabin’s wood-burning cast iron stove.
A welcome fire at the cabin.

Digging through the cupboards, I spied a crusty, globby Birmingham Stove & Range No. 8 skillet. I snatched it and set about cleaning it.

Yes, I used soap. I didn’t know where that pan had been or what those chunks were, and I wanted them gone before dinner. With a green scrub pad and a little Dawn, I scrubbed the cooking surface clean, tackled the rust underneath, dried the pan thoroughly, and wiped it with canola cooking oil spray.

Louise and Tom preferred their steaks medium rare; I’m a medium-to-well-done kind of girl. In more than 30 years of friendship, I don’t think they had ever let me cook steaks for them. My excitement over that skillet earned me a turn. And they were delicious!

How I Cook Steak in a Cast Iron Skillet

We used sirloin steaks about 1½–2 inches thick, seasoned with salt, pepper, and a little steak seasoning from the cupboard. Here’s the sear-and-oven method:

  1. Heat the oven to 400°F. Pat the steaks dry and season both sides.
  2. Heat the skillet over medium-high heat. Add a little cooking oil and let it heat until shimmering.
  3. Use tongs to place the steaks in the skillet. Sear until browned and the meat releases readily from the pan; ours took about four minutes. Turn and sear the other side.
  4. Using dry oven mitts—the handle will be blazing hot—transfer the skillet to the oven to finish cooking. Time varies with steak thickness and starting temperature, so check with a meat thermometer rather than relying on the clock.
  5. Rest the steaks loosely tented with foil before serving. USDA recommends cooking whole beef steaks to at least 145°F, followed by a rest of at least three minutes.

Our vegetables were already roasting in a foil packet: baby potatoes, asparagus, mushrooms, onion, garlic, and zucchini with a few pats of butter. We were all happy—including the dogs, who got a little leftover steak.

Steaks, Then Ms. Pac-Man

After dinner, Louise and I headed to a nearby pub, where I crushed her at Ms. Pac-Man, as I had been doing for 23 years.

Louise playing Ms. Pac-Man at a nearby pub.
Louise and Ms. Pac-Man. I was the victor!

Morning Leftovers

After a 32°F night in the tent, I was ready for another warm meal. Back at the cabin, we turned the leftover steak and a few eggs into breakfast hash.

I also found another BSR skillet and a dandy unmarked Wagner chicken pan with its lid. I cleaned them for our absent host as thanks for his hospitality.

All in all, a great—albeit chilly—weekend!

More about using and caring for vintage cast iron →

  1. Tom passed away on December 1, 2021. A version of this post was originally published in June 2018.