Griswold Cookware

Collectors and collections, History and Stories

Griswold, Lodge, Wagner, Favorite, Wapak, and More!

Griswold Cookware

Collectors and Collections,
History and Stories

Griswold, Lodge, Wagner, Favorite, Wapak, and More!

Home » Blog » My, How Vintage Cast Iron Cookware Prices Have Changed!

My, How Vintage Cast Iron Cookware Prices Have Changed!

In working to bring this blog back online, I have gone through many photos and documents I have accumulated over the years.

In doing this, I ran across some of the prices I paid at a 2012 auction. My, how prices have changed!

A sampling of Prices from a 2012 Vintage Cast Iron Auction

A few examples of my purchases in 2012:

Favorite Piqua Ware “Smiley” Skillet no. 7: $10.

Favorite Piqua Ware Smiley Vintage Cast Iron Skillet no. 7 with heat ring vintage antique cast iron skillet pan frying price how much value cost
$10! A quick review of eBay shows current asking prices of $50 – $125.

Griswold #7 Tite-Top Dutch oven with Lid. Large block logo EPU. $50.

Vintage Antique Griswold Cast Iron Tite Top Dutch Oven no. 7 price how much value cost
. Griswold Tite Top Dutch Oven no. 7 with Fully-Marked lid.

A quick review of eBay asking prices (remember to note the difference between asking and selling price, however!) shows a range of $150 – $300.

Griswold #8 “Iron Mountain” Dutch oven with lid, $50.

Griswold Iron Mountain antique vintage cast iron Dutch oven pot pan with lid cover price how much value cost
Iron Mountain Dutch Oven no. 8 with Cover.

eBay’s asking prices? $120 – $225.

Griswold Iron Mountain chicken pan with lid (an all-time favorite of mine; I can never resist these) $50.

Griswold Iron Mountain antique vintage cast iron chicken pan deep skillet frying fry fryer 8 with lid coverprice how much value cost
I bought an Iron Mountain set just like this in December 2022 at an online auction and paid $75 (not including buyer’s premium and estimated shipping), which I thought (and think) was a great price. eBay’s current asking prices are $148 – $275.

Griswold slant logo “ERIE” number 5 skillet with heat ring: $25.

griswold antique vintage cast iron skillet 5 724 slant italic erie heat ring pan fry frying price how much value cost griswald
This pan is not common. There were only two on eBay when I checked. One is offered at $165 and the other at $300.

Another not common pan – Griswold slant logo ERIE number 4. I paid $50.

griswold slant italic logo trademark 4 702 erie heat ring skillet cast iron pan fry frying price how much value cost griswald

There was just one on eBay when I checked, and it was being offered at the very optimistic asking price of $800.

Two Griswold slant logo “ERIE” skillets – a number 3 and a number 5: $25. Absent a seller with no information about the value of vintage cast iron cookware, I’d dare say you’d never get those two for $25 now.

Wagner stylized logo square skillet with glass lid: $25.

wagner ware square skillet cast iron pan fry frying skillet thumb rest glass lid cover price how much value cost
There are a bunch of these skillets on eBay right now; some at auction for very low starting bids. I did not immediately locate any of the square Wagner glass covers. Ironically, shortly after writing this article, a friend’s husband gave me this set from his collection.

Griswold large block logo smooth bottom chicken pan with fully-marked lid: $65. I’d buy these at that price all day every day!

griswold chicken pan antique vintage fry frying skillet deep self basting skillet lid 8 cast iron cover large block logo fully-marked lid price how much value cost griswald
I didn’t look this one up on eBay; I don’t need to as I know they sell for more than twice what I paid.

Griswold #5 plain skillet cover with large block logo EPU: $50.

griswold 5 plain cast iron skillet cover lid top pan griswald price how much value cost high dome
This size is not common, and a quick search of eBay did not reveal any for sale.

Griswold #8 plain skillet cover large block logo EPU: $30.

griswold plain skillet lid cover cast iron top pan frying fry antique vintage high dome price how much value cost
I saw several of these for sale on eBay with low starting bids, but one offered at a “buy it now” price of $160 (which is, IMO, high).

I purchased a handful of these Griswold fully-marked number 8 skillet lids with large block logo EPU for $35/each.
griswold 8 vintage antique self basting skillet lid cover raised letters pan fry frying price how much value cost
There are a number of these on eBay at auction and some with “buy it now” prices. The buy it now prices range from around $125 to $250.

I also have a recollection of a table filled with “common” Griswold (and other manufacturers) pans, and purchasing a number of #8 skillets for $20-$25 each.

Oh my. Times have changed!

Leave a Reply