Ask Mary: Lodge 3-Pour-Spout Skillet

Read to the end for—as Paul Harvey would say—“the rest of the story!”

Richard’s Question

Richard R. from Collierville, Tennessee, said:

Hello. I have attached two pictures of a three pour spout skillet I found at an estate sale. One picture is as found and the other after cleaning in lye tank. I have been hunting for cast iron 2-3 years and lurking on the internet sites and have purchased the red book and blue book for reference books. One of the books made reference to the [L]odge 3 spout. Do you think this is one? I am sorry I did not take [a] picture of the bottom, any info you can advise would be appreciated. I love hunting for cast iron and learning each facet about its history, etc. Thanks, Richard R.

Richard sent two photographs: one before cleaning and one after a lye bath.

Rare Lodge no-notch 3 pour spout antique vintage cast iron skillet pan
Richard’s skillet before cleaning.
Rare Lodge no-notch 3 pour spout antique vintage cast iron skillet pan
Richard’s skillet after cleaning in a lye bath.

From the photos, I knew right away that Richard had a Lodge 3-pour-spout skillet. It looked to be in beautiful condition.

Richard told me he paid $10 for the skillet at a Memphis, Tennessee, estate sale a few years back. Well, that was a lucky buy!

No-Notch Heat Ring

I asked Richard for a photograph of the bottom. Here are three more photos he sent:

Rare Lodge no-notch heat ring 3 pour spout antique vintage cast iron skillets, bottom
The unbroken heat ring on the bottom of Richard’s skillet.
Rare Lodge no-notch 3 pour spout antique vintage cast iron skillets, handle
Bottom of handle.
Rare Lodge no-notch 3 pour spout antique vintage cast iron skillets, top of handle raised 8
Top of handle.

I featured 3-pour-spout skillets in my little presentation at the Lodge Collector’s tent at the 2019 Cornbread Festival. They are rare and highly sought-after.

Set of three Rare Lodge 3 pour spout antique vintage cast iron skillets, two have one notch heat ring and one is a no notch heat ring.
Lodge 3-pour-spout skillets in sizes 6, 7, and 8. The top two have one-notch heat rings; the bottom skillet (size 6) has a no-notch heat ring. Photo and collection: Mark Goldschmidt.

Richard’s skillet is a “no-notch” skillet made by the Lodge Mfg. Co. in South Pittsburg, Tennessee, between 1910 and 1930. “No-notch” means the heat ring has no breaks. The number of notches—or lack of them—helps date Lodge skillets. You can read more in my post about Lodge collector John Clough.

2019: John Clough’s Value Estimate

I contacted Lodge historian and collector John Clough about Richard’s skillet. We had talked about 3-pour-spout skillets before, and I knew he could give me a reasonable estimate of its value.

Richard, John told me in late 2018 or early 2019 that your 3-pour-spout no-notch Lodge skillet would sell for at least $1,000. That’s quite a return on your $10 investment!

Congratulations, Richard! That’s a lovely and precious pan that you have there. Continue to enjoy your cast iron hunting!

Originally posted in 2019. The $1,000 estimate above dates to late 2018 or early 2019; values may have changed since then.

2024: The Rest of the Story

In early 2024, I was on the GCICA Facebook page, showing off some photos of Harold R. Henry’s collection. I was asked to post photos of Harold’s 3-pour-spout skillets. I knew Harold had one or more, but I didn’t have a picture. I did, however, have a photo of Mark Goldschmidt’s three 3-pour-spout skillets. I posted that photo, as did collector Matt Morris.

Matt shared a story: Mark had bought the number 6 three-spout skillet at an online Facebook auction for $1,626. The seller had paid $10 for it at an estate sale.

Small world! Two very valuable 3-pour-spout Lodge skillets, both found at estate sales for $10.

The moral of the story? You never know what you might find when you are on the cast-iron hunt!